Please help me spot the fake!

[Natalie123]

Hi!
i'm thinking of buying a luella giselle bag on ebay but i just don't know which one is authentic... /: these are the two options (i'm new to the forum so i can't post links) :

bag 1:
item number 270469290966
bag 2:
item number 220494954311

the first one looks pretty real to me so the question is what do you think about the second one?

thanx!!!!!

[boysRsmelly]

Here are the links for you:
Classic LUELLA GISELLE shoulder bag / tote in black - eBay (item 270469290966 end time Oct-22-09 13:16:16 PDT)
Authentic Large Luella Bartley Giselle Leather Bag - eBay (item 220494954311 end time Oct-21-09 03:57:54 PDT)

[boysRsmelly]

I don't know much about this designer. I agree that the first one looks pretty good. The second one looks like it might be okay too, but the seller doesn't offer very many pictures.
Maybe Deysa (VivaLaJuicy) can help you out. She has this exact bag.

[Natalie123]

thanks!
what do you think about them?